Verpies
Quote: "Word soup" or "word salad" is "confused or unintelligible mixture of seemingly random words and phrases".
I don't think this description applies to my posts, but that is my opinion and I cannot be my own judge.
I hereby ask other members to voice their opinions about this serious allegation.
Exactly,it does not fit at all, its clearly a defamatory statement and defies reality. Most of us who are here for a longer time cherish your way of approaching the different topics. This "Word soup" or "word salad" allegation is - from my perspective - deliberately focused on exactly that quality of yours to ask clear questions and not being distracted. The only method I know of, to clear the fog which is spread.
20 years ago I learned some management rules the hard way, i.e. I was ignorant of the behaviour-pattern of people under stress.
I had to clear up some serious failures in a coding, the IT-Department had programmed: I was responsible
of the overall layout ( design ) of the application ( a special cost-report ) and when I tested the report I realized that the responsible
programmer was ignorant of a certain data-processing-task as he had just left a starter-course of the special coding language.
During the discussion in which I showed the bugs in the coding, the IT-leader suddenly switched to a mode of attacking me ad hominem
in a very emotional way. That was the time to leave the discussion, just leaving the remark that there was a deadline he had to meet.
Whenever a situation like this occurs, a person with a good management-training-background knows what is going on psycholocally and should not
take this personally.
I predict that solarlab will not come back here - at least not with this user-Id -which I also regret because it was getting interesting at first.
Some remarks of mine about the Karnaukhova Generator-Paper:
First, the description of theory and the apparatus itself can be cut down in size by 50 %
Second, the theory is fuzzy for me and repeating it 5 times or more does not make it more clear.
Third, I absolutely disagree, that there is no current flowing in W2 of the left transformer including the antenna
I know this by my experience of more than 15 years. You just look at the two power-transistors driving W1 in push-pull mode then you
can estimate 20 to 40 watts at least....so this power just for creating no current ?
Forth, the picture of the apparatus does not fit the scheme in Fig. 3 and 4 so I can only guess that the left big helical coil which is placed
on a longer yellow coil on the left is a extension of this coil both being the antenna in Fig 3 and 4. Then what is the function of the right helical coil ?
Is this coil also an extension of the LC-Circuit of the right transformer ?
How do these to helical coils work ...transmitter and receiver ?
Overall this seems to me not a good description to start with.
Too much questions not answered...as verpies already stated.....we are waiting.
Mike